In my last posted blog, the ideal prerequisites for a Board of Education member were defined. In this blog, the candidates for the BOE will be named, with references to their individual qualifications and in the case of the one incumbent, past performance.
It is important to be educated on the candidates and to make your vote count. This blog is only one resource available on the candidates. Hopefully, The Fort Lee Patch and other sources will provide the community with a clear picture of these individuals prior to Election Day. Then it is up to the voters to make the correct decision in November.
As a community member who attends the majority of BOE meetings, I am well versed personally on all these candidates. While I am certain not everyone will agree, I believe the following to be a fair assessment of the 2012 slate.
David Sarnoff
Qualifications:
- Law Degree from Rutgers University
- Partner and Co-founder of Executive Search Firm
- Son and Daughter enrolled at School #1
- Coaches Youth Sports in Fort Lee: Soccer; Basketball; Baseball: and Softball
David has been extremely active at BOE meetings for several years. His emphasis has been on a more competitive bidding process for BOE contracts and a more careful scrutiny of all legal documents, i.e. specifically contracts for services. David is a major proponent of proper fiscal management by the Board in order to best utilize the limited resources available in the School Budget. David has also been a major advocate for a unified curricula in our elementary schools.
David appears to have the best credentials of all the candidates to fulfill the obligations of a BOE member. Having two young children in the school system will give David the extra impetus to work toward improving our schools.
Esther Silver
Qualifications:
- Graduate of Wellesley College
- Employed by Non-Profit Community Health Center in NYC as Human Resources Professional /Manager
- Certified EMT, 8 year veteran of Fort Lee Ambulance Corp.
- Two daughters currently enrolled in School #3.
- Current Board Member of School #3 PTA.
Esther has been attending BOE meetings for a number of months. She is married to Jeff Silver, ex-Fire Chief and a member of the Fort Lee Fire Department for many years. With two children in the school system, Esther has expressed the desire to become more involved in the BOE to improve the Fort Lee educational programs.
Esther has the professional credentials to potentially be a fine BOE member, and with two young children in the system, she has a vested interest in upgrading the Fort Lee school system.
Holly Morell
Qualifications:
- Fort Lee High School Graduate. No formal advanced education.
- Son currently at Fort Lee High School and a son at School #4.
- Freshman Academy Parent Committee member for Fort Lee High School.
- Involvement with School #4 PTA for many years
Holly has attended BOE meetings for many years and has been heavily involved in community service in our schools, as demonstrated by her PTA work and her participation in the Freshman Academy program. Over the years, she has shown a sincere interest in our educational system and a deep caring attitude toward the children of Fort Lee.
Holly has great energy and will always give her best effort. She has expressed willingness to obtain additional education on the responsibilities of BOE members in order to improve her knowledge on BOE issues. She currently has two children in the system and has a vested interest in the betterment of the Fort Lee schools.
John Bang
Qualifications:
- Graduate of Rutgers Law School, practicing Attorney
- Experience as a member of the BOE for last 4 years
- Son and Daughter enrolled at School#3
- Member of Fort Lee Korean-American Association, Local Community Service Organization
Unfortunately, with the qualifications that John Bang brings to the table, he has been an unproductive member of the BOE. He has two children in the system and should have a vested interest in improving our schools. However, his attendance record is subpar and his performance borders on abysmal.
At BOE meetings, John Bang has consistently shown poor judgment. He has supported inferior contracts for services in his tenure. He has been absent for key votes in 2012 (appointment of Superintendent of Schools and vote on $ 110,000 BGIA contract.) He appears to have violated the RICE notice on several occasions, by mentioning the names of teachers, principals, etc., without those individuals receiving proper notification that they were to be discussed at a public meeting.
When David Sarnoff and Tracy Mattei (later dropped out of race) filed petitions to run for the BOE, Mr. Bang challenged their petitions. Showing his true nature, John Bang chose to try to win at any cost, attempting desperately to eliminate the competition, rather than running on his record and/ or on his own merits. While what he did was perfectly legal, it shows a true flaw in his character.
John Bang does not react well at BOE meetings when criticism is set forth by attendees. The Board had proposed a contract for services by an out-of-state company with a Korean CEO. A question was raised about the possibility of this CEO being personally connected to a local Fort Lee Korean businessman. Instead of responding appropriately to a valid question, Mr. Bang publically embarrassed himself with accusations of racism. This is what might be termed the “Al Sharpton defensive syndrome”. When you cannot come up with an intelligent answer or are attempting to evade a question, you accuse the inquirer of racism.
There have been rumors in the community of Mr. Bang’s desire to be a Borough Councilman. While his attendance at BOE meetings has been subpar, Mr. Bang was able to find sufficient time to attend the Democratic National Convention. It would seem to be fair assessment that John Bang views this BOE position as a stepping stone in his political career. This would seem to be his priority, rather than improving the education for the children of Fort Lee.
==============================================
There are three seats open with four candidates vying for them. The future of Fort Lee education is in the hands of the voting public. It is time for the community to do “their homework” and elect those candidates that will perform with the dedication that our children truly deserve.
William Mays
6:30 pm on Friday, October 5, 2012
Well that totally isn't biased. You would entrust the person without a college degree with our kids education, but you bash the most qualified person there? Really?
Jack B Goode
5:17 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
its like bashing the most qualified Presidential candidate, Mr. Romney with over 25 years of successful business experience over Mr. Obama, a Harvard law professor and later a "community organizer"that knows nothing about running a business no less the US economy.
William Mays
10:35 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Yes, 25 years of spoiling other people's lives. I don't think you understand. No one is saying that Romney is bad because of his education, its because of what he did while he was in business.
Howard L. Pearl
12:57 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Robert:
Bloggers that blog anonymously have no credibility whatsoever. However, that being said, you bring up some valid points.
The electorate does not select the candidates. Individuals volunteer to run for office for their own personal reasons. No candidate meets all the criteria listed in my prior blog. We have to scrutinize the candidates that run, evaluate them based on those ideal qualifications, and hopefully elect the best ones.
I agree with you on one point. I would also prefer that Ms. Morell had a college degree and substantially more professional business experience, i.e. no argument there. That is why I noted in her educational profile: “No formal advanced education”. I could have chosen to omit this fact, but I believed it to be relevant. And I agree that Ms. Morell is not “polished”; she lacks public speaking skills and an aura that a business professional might carry. She is a simply and admirably a local housewife who desires to make the community a better place. However, who of the current BOE members is “polished”, certainly not John Bang!
If we were to base it strictly on credentials, John Bang wins hands down. But Holly Morell brings one thing to the table that John lacks totally, SINCERITY! Voters will have to decide who comes off as the better choice from the facts presented. These facts match Ms. Morell’s shortcomings versus John Bang’s ABYSMAL PERFORMANCE over the PAST FOUR YEARS!
I rest my case.
William Mays
1:02 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
What, you mean he doesn't suck up to you? It isn't your position to judge and smear other people, and it seems that that is all that you do.
Thomas A Bennett
1:53 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Howard, I have never had a real high opinion of you. What do these people have in common? Michael Dell, Henry Ford,Bill Gates,Andrew Jackson,John d Rockerfeller,Sheldon Adelson,J Paul Getty, Bobby Fischer,Charles Dickens,Winston Churchill,Andrew Carnegie, Richard Branson, Ray Bradbury, and many others.
Any one of them would have been wonderful on the School Board. And none of them have a college degree you elitist windbag.
William Mays
6:53 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
HAHA Sheldon Adelson. What you fail to say is that many of them GOT into a college, and later dropped out because of business obligations.
RITA D.
2:45 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
While education is important to anyone, it doesn’t completely make a person. Education comes in many forms. Just because a person has a college degree, does not make them smart or guarantee them a successful career. There are many kinds of life experiences that teach us more than any college education. As stated by others there are many successful people who did not attend college or who dropped out of college. Just to add a few to the list above, Bill Gates, Mark Zuckerberg, and Steven Spielberg. Drive and persistence are just as important to being successful as a formal education. Who are we to say to that Ms. Morell can’t do it or is not qualified because she lacks “Formal Education”? You can achieve success in anything you desire as long as you stick to the goals and are dedicated. Holly Morell over the past 13 years in the Fort Lee School District has shown her drive and dedication, to our schools and its children. Over the past years, our School Board has struggled. Maybe it is time for a change. Maybe we need someone with heart, compassion, and common sense, which is not something can be taught in school.
William Mays
6:54 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Bill Gates attended college and later dropped out, Mark Zuckerberg got into Harvard and later dropped out. Steven Spielberg attended college.
Tracy Mattei
3:29 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
H-
Everyone seems to be worried about a formal education, we have a board full of highly educated people....and it stagnates, sometimes lacks common sense, lacks knowledge about educational process, pedological needs, and positions of argument seem more about personal/cultural vendettas than about what is best for our community. Maybe one or two less attorneys/profesionals would be good and no politicians!
A question for you---why is a spouse an important candidate qualification? Will he be on the BOE making decisions?
I am looking for the candidate that will not allow themselves be persuaded by special interests groups and maintain the highest level of privacy for our children and employees ( I have yet to be assured of this). I would like one who understands that they are not to be involved in the day to day management of schools, refrain from undermining the chain of command, use the chain of command, trust the experts they have in place (trusting doesn't mean blindly trust) and understand that they are gaurdians of the bridge from community to the school district and vice versa. Not less than that and not more than that.
So I hope he community thinks very hard about the choices, because what is promised out here, in many instances, can never be on the other side of the table due to law, regulations, process, policy and need.
Howard L. Pearl
4:56 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Thomas Bennett, aka Republican candidate and November loser in the Fort Lee Borough Council elections. Mr. Bennett strives for recognition, but strikes out for lack of anything intelligent to say; whose brilliant campaign strategy is to eliminate candidate signs because “I am not a big believer of decorating the landscape with graffiti”.
If you were capable of reading and comprehending, Mr. Bennett, my blog supported Ms. Morell’s candidacy against another candidate with several college degrees.
Stating that a college education is preferable is not elitist, except to a misfit like you. Most families aspire to have their children attend college. And yes, some of our most brilliant minds did not attend college or dropped out before graduation. So, based on your comments, I assume that you are going to speak at the Fort Lee HS commencement ceremony and tell all the students that “college is not necessary” and that “I, Thomas A. Bennett guarantee success, a la Bill Gates, if you do not attend college”.
As for you “never having a very high opinion of me”, I personally consider that a compliment considering the total lack of respect that you command in our community.
William Mays
6:56 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Thomas is soooo successful, sometimes I just cry knowing that he probably makes $50,000 a year. I'm so jealous of him. Seriously Thomas, going to college is elitist now?
Thomas A Bennett
9:15 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
I dislike responding to blowhards but, I do want to clear up some facts. Democrats outnumber Republicans in Fort Lee by a margin of 3-1. WE have not had an elected Republican in Fort Lee for 17 years so, I am aware of the odds. If I strived for recognition, I would write a blog and kiss everyone's butt but, we have you for that.
Signs are a personal decision. If you attended the Homeowner's debate, you would know more. I had graduates working for me who couldn't find a job with that degree. Now, my point, attending college don't make you a better Board Member than someone who didn't. I was on the Board of Education with some housewives and they did a terrific job as did some college grads. Elitists like you who demand a college degree for almost everything makes you an elitist. Next time you call a plumber make sure he has a degree.
William Mays
10:37 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Except thats why he is a plumber, and not a school board member. Theres a difference between handling a septic tank and budgets for a school system.
Robert
10:32 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
The fact that someone like Tom Bennet can run for office
demonstrates that this a great country. I am just concerned that if he gets elected ( fat chance) the Martians will start to invade.
Thomas A Bennett
9:22 am on Sunday, October 7, 2012
This is my final statement on this subject. I do no respond to annonymous bloggers who refuse to Identify themself. Their comments I give no credence to. After all someone using a man's name might in fact be a teenage girl and vice-versa. So, if you are a man or women, prove it.
Robert
10:17 am on Sunday, October 7, 2012
So Mr. Bennett let me get this straight are you in some way comparing Holly Morrell to Bill Gates, Henry Ford,
Andrew Jackson etc? Yes those are just the people I am thinking about when I think of Holly. And when I think of Ronald Regan I am thinking about you.
Anna
5:06 pm on Monday, October 8, 2012
No wonder more people don't want to run for BOE or other elected office in Fort Lee. When they do they are dissected and denigrated by random people on Patch or other forums, or are condescended to by people who claim to be supporting them. Any caring and competent adult, particularly those with kids in the school system, should have a right to offer their time and energy to the BOE, the PTA or any other entity without the fear that people who don't know him or her well will characterize them unfairly on Patch or somewhere else. Unfair characterizations include statements like "unpolished" or "simply a housewife". These are sexist comments to boot. Who would want to expose themselves to all that? I give anyone who would lots of credit.
Tracy Mattei
7:59 pm on Monday, October 8, 2012
Billy- There are already people on the BOE without college degree, but a wealth of life/business experince that is worth listening to....so don't count anyone out quite yet
William Mays
8:43 pm on Monday, October 8, 2012
Like who? I need to know, so I don't vote for them next time.
Art Elmers
11:22 am on Tuesday, October 9, 2012
Wow, How did this discussion go off on such a tangent? It started with Howard giving his opinion on the qualities and qualifications of those running for BOE. It turned into an excursion into the twilight zone. While you might not agree with Howard's opinion, I think we can all agree with his right to have and express it. If you feel that his opinions are valid or not then weigh that together with all the other information you can and vote for who YOU feel will do the best job of representing you. Howard may be abraisive at times but he lets you know where he stands on many issues. And he certainly encourages vocal disagreement. But so can Billy, Tom, Robert, and others, perhaps even myself, who contribute to the discussion.
This is America. Let's not belittle people just because they run for office. Some may not have the qualifications you think they should have but please allow all of us to make the final decision by using our right to vote. I have sat on many Board of Directors both where I live and where I work. I can remember fellow members talking about discouraging or even trying to prevent people from running. I always would not stand for it. Our democracy is only as strong as our commitment to it's principles. And one of them is the principle that anyone, regardless of their qualifications or lack of, has the right to run for office. And I strongly believe that those choosing to run should not be belittled for their beliefs. Hopefully many agree with me.