patching...
Update: Got a news tip? E-mail james.kleimann@patch.com »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Fort Lee BOE Accepts School Superintendent's Resignation

Fort Lee Board of Education accepts the resignation of Steven Engravalle as Superintendent of the Fort Lee School District.

 

The Fort Lee Board of Education accepted the resignation of School Superintendent Steven Engravalle during Monday's special work session.

When asked for a reason for the Board's decision to accept Engravalle's resignation, Board Attorney Dennis McKeever said, "The relationship between the Board and Mr. Engravalle has been irretrievably severed and broken."

The Board voted on three resolutions regarding the separation:

  1. The Board approved the separation of service agreement of Steven Engravalle effective March 4, 2013.
  2. The Board accepted the letter of resignation of Steven Engravalle as Superintendent effective March 4, 2013.
  3. The Board appointed Assistant Superintendent Dr. Sharon Amato as acting Superintendent of Schools effective March 5, 2013.

In response to a question posed by Paula Colbath regarding the terms of Engravalle's separation from the district, McKeever said that he was not able to divulge the strategy or the negotiations regarding the separation of services agreement.

McKeever did say that the terms were arrived through mutual compromise between the two parties.

Included in the terms, Egravalle will be paid a total of $66,624.16. Colbath, asking precisely what that number represented--salary and/or expenses--was told by McKeever that the specific terms of the agreement could not be discussed at this point.

Additionally, the Board has not yet determined the length of time that Amato will be Acting Superintendent, nor were they prepared to comment on their plans going forward to secure a permanent superintendent for the district.

With the exception of Board member Holly Morell, the Board voted in favor of passing all three resolutions. Morell voted in favor the resolution appointing Amato as Acting Superintendent.

Board member Charlie Luppino was not present at the meeting.

At the completion of the vote, some Board members offered their statements. All agreed that the decision was not an easy one to make.


"This is not a decision we took lightly," Ester Han Silver said. "At the end of the day we had to decide what would be best for the students, the district, the staff."

Candee Romba said that the board is looking forward to getting something done in the district.

David Sarnoff came to the conclusion that the only right decision in the interest of the educational welfare of the children of Fort Lee "is to pass the resolutions to move forward to bring Fort Lee public schools to another level."

Helen Yoon said that the decision was difficult for her because she had opposed the appointment of Engravalle.

Peter Suh agreed that in order to move forward the decision had to be made to vote in favor of the resolutions. "It's a result that had to be," he said. "As we move forward we'll be able to do things we were unable to do previously, so this is a good step for us. It's a step forward."

Morell said that she wants the healing to start, but added, "I just felt this was not the right way for me. And that's why I voted the way that I did."

In a prepared statement, Board President Jimmy Park said that only time will tell if this is the right decision, but "it frees this district to move forward so we can focus on what we're supposed to be focused on--providing our children with the best education that we can afford in the safest environment that we can provide."

Park said that fact does not change or hide the fact that "this decision is distasteful."

"The system is broken," Park continued. "Our current predicament shines a painful light to the undeniable fact that we need a fundamental change in the way that we govern and run our public school systems."

"Until that day, however much it sickens me to my stomach to reach the decision that we have made tonight--whether you agree or disagree with our resolution--I hope you can agree with me when I tell you that this board is nothing less than the personification of true guardians and advocates of our children who we will protect and fight within the system that is hopelessly slanted toward the special interest groups within this system under the guise of children's best interest," Park ended.

Correction: Board member Joseph Surace voted in favor of the resolutions.

As of press time, Steven Engravalle had not responded to a message asking for comments.

Click here to sign-up for Fort Lee Patch's Breaking News Alerts.

Related Topics: Fort Lee Board of Education, Steven Engravalle, and fort lee schools

William Mays

12:56 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

About time. Now he can go wreck some other district, but hopefully they'll google his name before trying to hire him.

Reply

Fort Lee Truth

8:10 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Hopefully, anyone who had anything to do with that ridiculous contract also will submit their resignation.

Also, why did Holly Morell vote "no" on one of the resolutions? Her comment about "was not right for me" is not exactly a detailed explanation.

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Ann Piccirillo

8:33 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

At the close of the meeting, Board members made their statements, but declined comment afterwards for further clarification.

Anna

8:10 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

This has been a very painful time for Fort Lee. I hope we can now get together and support the board and the interim as a community so that the school system can move forward.

Reply

Martha Cohen

8:10 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

The only way the system could be "hopelessly slanted toward the special interest groups within this system under the guise of children's best interest" is if our elected representatives to allow this to happen. If that is the view of some on the board, then they should resign, too, right along with Engravalle. Anyone who is even slightly aware of things happening in the school system knows that many on this board were responsible for hiring this Superintendent against the wishes of many in the community which led to a lot of back door business - no transparency here. In fact, the President of the board - who sent his child out of district - left shortly after this vote. So let's begin with real transparency. We, the Fort Lee taxpayer, are going to pay the $66K to Engravalle so why is there secrecy to what it is for? Let's try something new - transparency where it is the parents and taxpayers - the people that do care about the children and their education - get to know everything and have their knowledgeable representatives at the table when these things are discussed, considered and voted on. Wow, now that would truly be a new beginning for our children!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Robert

2:51 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

yes transparancy in government Martha is a good idea. Care to explain how transparent the appointment of Judith Fisher to the Lodi DMV was? Yes please tell us that out of the entire state of New Jersey how she was the most qualified applicant .
We are waiiting Martha ......

Comment_arrow

Jack B Goode

11:55 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Any matters related to a Government employee's salary,contract, appointment,termination,evaluation or other related issues ,are exempt under the Sunshine Law and have the right to negotiate in private,with an attorney present with the governing body, this has nothing to do with "transparency", but you should know that as a past and current Republican council candidate.

oracle

8:10 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

$66,624 in severance for a job he held for only 9 months, and didn't show up for 6! I understand they were afraid of lawsuits, but I do not understand why they paid him anything other than the 2 weeks you get at any other job. He stopped showing up, and stopped doing his job with either false, or no excuses. If you can't get rid of someone for that without paying them tens of thousands of dollars, what can you get rid of them for? That could have paid for so many things: teacher's aids, computers, sports equipment, extra curricular activities, AP classes, etc. So many of these things we are asking students to pay out of pocket for. The public education system process of hiring and firing ineffective superintendents is clearly broken.

Engravalle is mocking everyone to the end when he posted this morning on twitter: "Who dares, wins".He is laughing all the way to the bank.

Reply

Steve McDonald

8:10 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

I wonder what/who the next target will be ? Some of these people aren't happy unless they are complaining about something. Gotta love the "community activists".

Though I am not happy with the education my children are currently getting, I can't blame the Superintendent for it.

Reply

Howard L. Pearl

8:56 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

$ 66k is the price we pay for a poorly prepared contract by a BOE attorney, approved by Board members and the County BOE! If this was a standard contract, then the standard has to change for the future.
The current Board did what was necessary to move forward. Fort Lee was in stasis; we needed to move forward. It was the only escape from a very tragic situation.

Reply

Paul Umrichin

2:51 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Judging by the vote I would say Holly and Joe voted no because OF the payout. Maybe they didn't want to pay that amount and that's why their vote went that way. I can't believe that either of them said no because they were hoping to keep Mr Engravalle on as the Superintendent. The system is broken as Jimmy said last night but as one slogan reads..... Think Globally... Act Locally . This applies here, we can fix our part o the system with hopes of continued growth and example setting. The board has already begun its action with lots on deck. With this over focus can continue on everything else. Good luck to the BOE.

Reply

Rona

2:51 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

The board itself is it's own mess that needs to be cleaned up first. The next time use a search firm to evaluate people don't just hire them and ignore their suggestions. In Engravalle's case looking at his LinkedIn account it would have been easy to see how little time he spent at any of his other endeavors, and maybe reading and checking on his resume. In the meanwhile $67K in severance might as well have tossed the money down a storm sewer. And we have a rushed decision on school security that Engravalle instituted after he came back from his time off.

Reply

carol simon

2:51 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

I think the Board of Ed.was as transparent as possible and cut their losses efficiently.
I am quite impressed with the Board Members, and realize human beings make mistakes and sometimes pay for them. Mr. Park appears to bring a sensible, caring point of view to his position, and Levine (i heard) had a child who needed services in another district. However, he stayed on to do his duty. I'm not sure who the special interest groups are, although I'd like to know. I think it is transparency that we know "the deal", the contract was broken and that was the outcome. It seems to me that sharing details have legal implications. I don't think this Engravalle saga is a tragic situation. No tears will be shed and now there is closure. Hopefully the DOE and attorney will learn from their costly mistakes.

Reply

Paul Umrichin

11:55 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Is this pending approval process a new thing?

Reply

Robert

11:55 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Who do you think wrote that comment for Jimmy Park?

Reply

carol simon

11:55 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

I think the DOE did a decent job rectifying a mistake that could have been prevented. I'm not sure who these special interests groups are that were responsible for poor judgement regarding hiring and for the contract of Engravalle. This idea of Special interest groups warrants more investigation.The idea that Mr. Levine, the former President left after his vote with shame or blame was not what I thought to be common knowledge , that his child needed special services and he served here in her absence. Is it a conspiracy or a mistake. I don't think it's a tragic. No tears will be shed.Even though this blunder appears to be the FLBOE and it's members I am impressed with the board, including Mr. Park as he has a reflective way of leading that sets a comfortable tone. There is a lot to be learned for the board, the attorney and the parents/public from this debacle. It seems that the mistakes were quite transparent. I feel relieved that Superman can take flight!

Reply

Thomas A Bennett

9:43 am on Wednesday, March 6, 2013

First, I am glad to see Steve leave, it will be good for the community and the kids in the longrun.
to Robert: Don't confuse the issue. Martha did not appoint anyone to anything so asking her to explain is like asking you to explain anything that Obama has done, it is not relevant to our current situation.
Engravalle has resigned, NOW, where is Lupino's resignation letter? Apparently he is not coming to any more meetings.
When I was on the Board, they hated me because I wanted to discuss most things in public because I believed that was the way it should be done. we had a great Lawyer named Joe Skelly who told me what was legally ok to talk about. There is too much secrecy on this Board, they should share more info. Remember some of these folks appointed Engravelle.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Robert

9:13 pm on Wednesday, March 6, 2013

Thomas the issue Martha was discussing was " transparancy" in government. Well then she needs to be consistent . Funny how she has no response to the issue I raised. Yet she is quick to criticize the Mayor when makes an appointment.
Yet when Kathy Donovan appoints Judith Fischer to a job she has zero expertise I did not hear her voice any objection .

Comment_arrow

Stefanie Stuart

9:13 pm on Wednesday, March 6, 2013

This Board has 4 new members compared to the one that appointed Mr Engravalle, and apparently two of the old board members that are on the current board voted no on Mr Engravalle's appointment. This means that only 3 of the current members had anything to do with where we are now. In the interests of the district, it is time to let bygones be bygones, take the lessons we've learned and move forward, focussing our energy on what is best for the kids and the district as a whole.

carol simon

9:43 am on Wednesday, March 6, 2013

Sorry to be repetitive, I did not think my first comment was posted, so i wrote again., OOPS

Reply

Thomas A Bennett

9:17 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013

To Robert: Because you are an anonymous person and a coward hiding behind a first name who no one here knows, this will be my last communication with you. Come out of the closet and give your real name then, what you say will be accountable to you. Notice that I will not address anything that the late Billy Mays says because he is also a coward to use its real name. so, until you do, I will just assume that you are a Democrat clinger-on trying to win favor with the current administration.
I will advise you that the Republican Club meets on the third Tuesday of the month at the Fort Lee VFW Hall on Center Ave, Fort Lee. Any questions you may have can be addressed in person with any person which you may have an issue, except me. I am on vacation until May 3.
Until you step up and identify yourself, I will ignore anything you post and I advise all others to pay you no mind, you do not exist.

Reply
Comment_arrow

William Mays

11:16 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013

Obviously someone has not synchronized with the internet age.

Comment_arrow

Gene

8:58 pm on Sunday, March 10, 2013

Thomas, I agree 200%. This character “Robert” has nothing constructive to say just sniping at people and writing pure demagoguery and nonsense. Let’s flag him out of Fort Lee. - Gene Geiler.

Joes

5:23 pm on Thursday, March 7, 2013

Now that we have gotten rid of Mr.Engravelle , let us hope that the BOE finds a strong and competent leader for our school system. Do not repeat the mistakes from the recent past and yes make the board more transparent . My only fear that Fort Lee has become such a joke that any quality superintendent will not want to come here. Remember that the superintendent should run the school system and not the BOE but the board should advise and be a partner with the next school chief. Let's give the BOE a chance to to their job and if they don't next election vote for someone else. PS., please write a contract that puts the students and the Fort Lee taxpayers first instead of the superintendent.

Reply

Frank Collura

11:19 am on Wednesday, March 13, 2013

To anyone goggling the name of Engravalle with regards to doing business with him in the future, please note that he has been a loser and a liar and a opportunist. Loser -- He has no doctorate, his school is one that exists only on the internet. He was no skill in dealing with groups of people, like a school board. He deals with problems by not showing up -- taking sick leave until it runs out. Liar -- He was not married to the woman he claims was his wife. Opportunist -- rather than quit like a "man" with a moral compass he spent most of his tenure doing two things -- attending school conferences (off site and at the expense of the school board) in anticipation of his new career path direction and negotiating an early termination of his contract. Summation -- a carpetbagger in the worst version of the word's definition. Don't hire him!! Don't do business with him!!

Reply

Ryan

8:44 am on Saturday, March 16, 2013

yet on his twitter, he says that the board and the public don't work for the kids. Um... you don't work at all!

Reply

Robert

10:04 am on Wednesday, April 3, 2013

Boy Frank is starting to Sound like Paula Colbath!

Reply

Robert

10:04 am on Wednesday, April 3, 2013

Oh Gene you are the genius who is a Real Estate Broker in Ft Lee and tells his clients (if he has any) the schools are horrible. I bet by now you need a loan to feed your family . Getting rid of me will not prevent you from making anymore stupid comments , or I would leave .

Reply

Sterlingave

4:01 am on Sunday, April 21, 2013

Let's all really remember and promise to remember the pedestal that our beloved, self-righteous governor put SE on - do not have a short memory folks.

Reply

Leave a comment